I discovered Shoebox Zoo quite recently, nearly 18 years after it originally aired (as of the time this review was originally written). Truthfully, I went into it with very low expectations, and was very hesitant to check it out at first, but my curiosity was piqued and so I ended up deciding to watch it. Much to my shock, I ended up enjoying it quite a lot, so much so that I’d even rank it among my favorite shows of all time. As such, I wanted to make this review in order to share my thoughts on some of the main aspects of the show, among other things.

To start things off, I’d like to talk about the central focus of the show, the titular “shoebox animals”, since I firmly believe the show did a tremendous job with them. They’re incredibly fun characters and add so much life to just about every scene they’re in, and while they primarily adhere to one defining personality trait, on top of initially being quite secretive and mistrustful, each of them goes through their own little character arcs (with some being more subtle then others), making them feel quite fleshed out by the end.

The animals are further bolstered by the clever editing, superb voice talents and surprisingly great CGI animation that go into making them possible in the first place. Everything is so well done to the point that, for a majority of the scenes, I genuinely had a hard time believing that the CGI creatures weren’t actually there, despite being fully aware that they most certainly weren’t.
In contrast to this, however, are the CGI used for for the magic spells cast by several characters throughout the story, which look quite dated and rough barring some minor exceptions. While some might find that a tad bit immersion-breaking, it didn’t really bother me all too much, and didn’t hamper my viewing experience in any way.

Moving on to the actors, I greatly enjoyed their usually over-the-top and hammy performances, with some of my personal favorites being David McKay’s role as the lovable henchman McTaggart and Natascha Girgis’ role as the eccentric spirit medium Aurora Dexter, among others.
In regards to Vivien Endicott Douglass’ performance as the protagonist, Marnie McBride, I must say that while I’ve seen no shortage of ire being directed towards it and can understand and even agree with some of the criticisms towards her acting, I personally didn’t find myself having any major problems with it. As a matter of fact, I thought Vivien did a great overall job in playing the role of a young girl who has to grieve with the loss of her recently deceased mother, but gets caught up in this strange and otherwordly scenario that just about entirely clashes with her everyday life and serves to complicate her already complex situation even further.

As for the show itself, I found myself pleasantly surprised when I saw some serious topics being tackled within the plot, including those that I could relate to and/or appreciate in some way, and felt that they gave the show a somewhat mature feel overall while still having no shortage of silly moments and banter. The flexibility of the show’s tone lends it this sort of balance, a balance that ends up making it suitable to watch for both younger and older audiences, with both being able to connect with certain aspects of the show, some of which even overlap depending on taste and preference.
I’d also like to note that I enjoyed both of the show’s 2 seasons thoroughly, and even with the occasional weird story beat and the reliance on some done to death tropes, as well as Season 2’s near total absence of my favorite character, I still found myself having an absolute blast from start to finish.

While I could go on, I recommend that you try watching Shoebox Zoo for yourself and see if you enjoy it, as it can be rather hit or miss from what I could gather, and you might not have the same level of enjoyment which I had while watching it. With that being said, I personally enjoyed just about every second of Shoebox Zoo, despite it being far from perfect and aging rather poorly in some aspects. The show fully embraces its silliness but still manages to have genuinely raw and emotional moments, along with a fantastical world that is both fascinating to learn about and rich in lore and potential for theory-crafting. Those, in combination with me being able to feel the passion that went into making such a seemingly nonsensical concept for a show into a reality oozing at just about every moment, made Shoebox Zoo an amazing and truly unforgettable watch for me.